FM16: The Return To Schalke 04


In FM15, I had one of my most enjoyable saves ever. I started off at Dynamo Kyiv but moved on to Schalke and really grew to love the team. It was an extremely trophy laden spell. I was there for 5 years and won five Bundesliga titles on the bounce. I thought it would take longer to overthrow the mighty Bayern, especially considering Schalke hadn’t finished near the top of the table in a long time, we were very successful though. There was a good core of homegrown talent in the squad which I supplemented by excellent players from the transfer market. You can read about how it went, further down on my blog.

For this year’s game, I’ve taken a while to decide what team to go, but Schalke was always one of my preferred choices. I’ve got to have some sort of connection to the team and I already had that with Schalke due to my previous save. It might seem a bit boring to go back to some, but I’m sure there’s plenty of people that do that. I really like the Bundesliga, there’s some great teams and great players plying their trade there.

The aim this year is quite similar to last year. I want long-term success but I’ll be putting more of an emphasis on the youth development side of things. I might restrict the purchase of foreign players as the game goes on, but I’ll decide as time goes by what my policy will be.

The squad looks pretty decent. Goretzka, Sané, Meyer, Geis and Ayhan are all capable of developing into top players. There’s some decent experience in there too with the likes of Fährmann, Höwedes and di Santo.

Someone will likely ask why Hojbjerg hasn’t been mentioned and that is because I sent him back from his loan. I’d rather have players in my squad that will be here for the long haul, not much point in me spending time developing players for Bayern.

Hiring and Firing

As soon as I start any save, before I look at the team, tactics or transfers, I assess the staff. There’s always going to be a few sackings. Some of the coaching staff were ok, but I decided to ship them all out and bring in my own guys. I could employ 7 coaches, an assistant manager and a Head Of Youth Development. I decided to go with two fitness coaches, four categorised coaches (ball control/defending/attacking/shooting) and one goalkeeping coach. Where possible, I tried signing coaches with similar tactical ideas to me and with good personalities.

staff 1516

Bernhard Peters is the jewel in the crown for me. His personality and attributes make for a perfect Head Of Youth Development. Hopefully he can help find the best youngsters around for me. I read a lot about staff personalities on Cleon’s blog over at SI Sports Centre, definitely check that blog out if you haven’t already.

I brought in a mostly new scouting team, with the focus mainly on Germany. I also brought in three new physios. I’ll not bore you by going through them all, so I’ve just included the staff overview screen so you can see how we compared to everyone else in the league.staff overview1516

Setting Up A Tactic

Fitting the best players into a working tactic can take a bit of time and jiggery-pokery. After assessing the squad and the best players I knew how I wanted to set things up.

I had a tactical idea that I really loved on FM15, but never used in any of my blogged saves. I based the shape and basic idea on Arrigo Sacchi’s AC Milan side of the late 80’s. It’s basically a 442, but with one of the wingers in the attacking strata, cutting inside. Milan played with their strongest winger on the right, but our best winger, Leroy Sané, is left footed, so it’s flipped to reflect this.

After reading lots about how they setup, I realised it was almost impossible to replicate in Football Manager, but I tried and this is what I’ve come up with. It’s not a perfect replica of Sacchi’s Milan, I just used the idea and worked towards something that worked well and had a good balance. I’ll be tinkering as the season goes. It’s not fluid yet, but we’ve been playing pretty well. This is how it looks. I really wish SI would include a “Flip Tactic” option, that just flips your tactic to the opposite side and carries your roles/instructions instead of having to setup the tactic again. One for the suggestion box I suspect.1516 tactic

I’m not going give out the instructions as I’m not wanting to focus on that too much. I’m looking to win the ball back high up the pitch, keep a tight defence and score plenty of goals using the wings.


After working out the best players I had to work out who wasn’t going to make it or fit in. Chelsea were straight in for Joël Matip at the start of summer. I got a deal worth £22.5m plus 20% of any future fee. I have three very good centre backs and a couple of decent youngsters, so I was ok with this deal. Höger, Santana and Boateng followed shortly after, all out of contract at the end of the season, I got £6m for them and a good chunk off of my wage budget. Klaas-Jan Huntelaar is a player I suspected wouldn’t work in the system due to his lack of pace. With his wages being £96k p/w, when Tottenham offered £5.5m, I quickly accepted. Sascha Riether was released after having no interest in him. Obviously, Hojbjerg returning to Bayern counts towards an outgoing transfer as well.

I only signed two players in the summer, which is a bit of a rarity for me. I needed a quick intelligent goalscorer. I scouted about and eventually settled on Wissam Ben Yedder from Toulouse. His price was well within range and his attributes were what I was looking for. £9m was a decent price I felt. I also bought Norwegian youngster, Kristoffer Ajer for £1.5m. He’ll get games in my midfield, mainly in the Cup and Europa League.


We have a couple of players out on loan this season, a couple of which I’m looking forward to getting back. Donis Avdijaj was beastly for me on FM15 and I think he’s got the potential to be the same in this game. Christian Clemens could be a decent squad player and Timon Wellenreuther is a long-term replacement for Fährmann in goal.

First Season Goals

The obvious thing for me this season is to get Champions League qualification by finishing in the top three. Not an easy task with Dortmund, Wolfsburg and Leverkusen all vying for two of the spots with one, inevitably being taken by Bayern. Not unachievable though. I’ll be rotating for the Cup and Europa League, so I’m not pushing to hard on those fronts.

Champions League football would increase our reputation to attract players as well as boosting our finances. The bank balance is very solid, but we always want more.


  1. We (AC Sparta Prague) played with Schalke two matches in recent weeks in real life so I know current Schalke’s squad very well. Players like Geis, Sané or Meyer are incredible but Choupo-Moting was the best player in both matches against Sparta.

    1. There’s interest in England for him in my game. There was a bid from Tottenham at the start of the season, but I rejected it. He’s only got 2years on his contract and isn’t a first teamer so I might end up cashing in. He’s put in some decent performances, but mainly from the bench.

  2. Terrible club choice 😛 But I’m interested in seeing how things will go out.

    About Choupo-Moting, if you get a decent price, I see no reason to keep him. At least in real life, he has not the ability to be a serious contender for a starting place in the long run. Cashing in and giving younger players the place as substitute seems for me as the best move.
    Apart from that, I liked that you sent Höjbjerg back. Bayern are already good enough without other teams wasting their time to make their players better.

    1. Not a Schalke fan? Hahaha
      Choupo-Moting has performed ok over the season with some assists and a few important goals, but he’s not a player I’m counting on for the future. I suspect it’ll be a case of moving him on once the season is over and Avdijaj comes back. There’s a youngster called Felix Platte that has played a few games this season and grabbed 8 or 9 goals as well.
      Yeah, I want to develop players that I can benefit from long term. If I had no money to get someone else, I’d have kept Höjbjerg.

      1. Ahhh, got you. I like both teams, but when playing as Schalke, I always want to beat Dortmund due to the rivalry.

        Great youngsters at Schalke. Got a great U19 team right now.

  3. Awesome write up dude! Just wondered how you went and what staff you hired? I always seem to keep whoever the team has, as I find it hard signing the guys I want from bigger clubs or finding guys on the market??

    And do you share your tactics anywhere? I’m just curious to how you setup as I normally play a 4-1-2-1 or 4-1-3 with a false nine and wing backs.

    I normally base my game on pace, out wide and a good counter attack and high pressure.
    (This was with my Liverpool save, hoping to keep most of the philosophies from that team if possible )

    Thanks in advance mate 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s